Three mechanics claim to increase the average basket: offering a gift above a threshold, granting a percentage discount, or covering the shipping costs. All three work. They do not cost remotely the same.
This article compares their effect on real margin, with a worked scenario. For the technical setup of the gift at a threshold, see the article devoted to its configuration.
The framework of the calculation
Take a shop whose average basket is 60 euros excluding shipping, with a gross margin of 40%, meaning 24 euros of margin per order. The objective is to raise the average basket to 75 euros.
The point most reasoning misses: the mechanic also applies to customers who would have passed the threshold anyway. That is the subsidy cost, and it is often greater than the gain.
Assume the following distribution across 1,000 orders, before any operation:
400 orders under 50 euros, average basket 35 euros.
350 orders between 50 and 75 euros, average basket 60 euros.
250 orders above 75 euros, average basket 105 euros.
The threshold is set at 75 euros in all three scenarios. Identical behavioural assumption in each case: 30% of the orders in the middle band rise to the threshold, meaning 105 orders going from 60 to 76 euros.
Scenario 1: a 10% discount above 75 euros
On the 105 orders that rise, the basket goes from 60 to 76 euros. Margin before discount: 30.40 euros. Discount of 7.60 euros. Final margin: 22.80 euros, against 24 euros previously.
The rise in basket loses margin on those orders. It is counter-intuitive but arithmetic: at a 40% margin, a 10% discount on the price consumes 25% of the margin, which 16 euros of extra turnover does not make up.
On the 250 orders already above the threshold, the discount applies with nothing in return: 10.50 euros of discount per order, meaning 2,625 euros of margin lost.
Result: around 2,750 euros of margin lost across 1,000 orders.
Scenario 2: the gift at the threshold, purchase cost 4 euros
The gift is a product whose purchase cost you bear, not its selling price. That is the structural difference from a discount.
On the 105 orders that rise: margin of 30.40 euros, minus 4 euros of gift, meaning 26.40 euros. A gain of 2.40 euros per order, or 252 euros.
On the 250 orders already above: 4 euros per order, meaning 1,000 euros of cost with nothing in return.
Result: around 750 euros of margin lost. Three times less than the discount, for the same effect on the basket.
Free Gift Above a Cart Threshold — PrestaShop 8 & 9Free gift at cart threshold — clean, measurable, no price hack.€59.00
Scenario 3: free shipping above 75 euros
Assumption: dispatch costing 6 euros, charged at 5.90 euros to the customer below the threshold.
On the 105 orders that rise: margin of 30.40 euros, minus 6 euros of shipping absorbed, meaning 24.40 euros. A marginal gain of 0.40 euros per order.
On the 250 orders already above, if free shipping already existed, the cost is nil. If it is new, it represents 1,500 euros.
Result: between a 40-euro gain and a 1,460-euro loss, depending on whether free shipping already existed.
This scenario is the most sensitive to the level of the threshold and to the real cost of dispatch. On a heavy product shipped at 12 euros, free shipping destroys the margin of the middle band.
What the calculation does not say
Three effects escape the table, and two of them work in favour of the gift.
Perceived value. A gift displayed at a commercial value of 19 euros costs you 4 euros. The customer compares 19 euros with a discount of 7.60 euros. The gap between perceived value and real cost exists neither for the discount nor for the shipping.
Clearing stock. The gift can be an end of line or a slow-moving product, which turns a cost into a clearance.
Habituation. That is the unfavourable effect. Permanent free shipping becomes an expectation and stops being a lever. A recurring discount resets the perceived reference price. The gift, if it changes regularly, escapes that better.
A legal point to watch: the gift must be presented as such, with a coherent value. A premium whose announced value is far above its real value falls under misleading commercial practices.
Where to place the threshold
This is the variable with the greatest effect, more than the choice of mechanic.
Three rules drawn from the calculation above.
The threshold should sit between 15 and 30% above the average basket. Too low and you subsidise orders that would have reached it on their own. Too high and nobody rises.
Look at the distribution, not the average. If half your orders already sit above the threshold you are considering, your subsidy cost will absorb the whole gain.
The threshold should fall just above a common product price. A threshold of 75 euros on a catalogue whose items cost 20 euros leads the customer to a basket of 80 euros. A threshold of 70 euros leads to the same basket with a more attainable threshold.
The recommendation
On the figures above, the ranking is clear: the gift costs three times less than the discount for an identical effect on the basket, and it keeps room for manoeuvre on perceived value.
Two reservations, however. The gift means stock to manage, weight to factor into the dispatch and a product to renew. Those are operating costs that do not appear in the calculation and that can, in a small operation, exceed the 2,000 euros of annual difference calculated.
Free shipping remains preferable in one precise case: when your shipping costs are an identified point of friction in your basket abandonments. There it is no longer about raising the average basket but about unblocking a conversion, and the calculation is different.
Redo the table with your own figures before deciding. The three numbers that matter are your margin rate, the share of orders already above the threshold, and the real purchase cost of the gift you have in mind. The Free Gift Above a Cart Threshold module handles the mechanic on PrestaShop 8 and 9: configurable threshold, choice of gift by the customer from a selection, progress bar in the cart, and exclusion of products already on promotion from the threshold calculation.